Public hearing on coyotes

Dateline: Sat 06 Nov 2010

The following info is courtesy of Cecilia Lambert, who runs a coyote rescue operation in Indiana:


Florida’s Fish and Wildlife Commission voted to ban permanently penning, the practice of training dogs to chase and kill foxes and coyotes within enclosures. Several states including NC and SC are considering similar action

It appears that Indiana’s captive wildlife may not be so fortunate.

 On Nov.16, the IN Natural Resources Commission will address a proposal to establish regulations governing the one penning operation in the state, which has been investigated by the DNR and is expected to be licensed   According to Linnea Petercheff, operations staff specialist with the In Div. Of Fish and Wildlife, “Regulations will provide for the welfare of the coyote as well as provide for fair chase and prevent new pens from opening.”  Opponents of penning see it differently. They point to photos, undercover videotapes and eyewitness accounts of captive coyotes and foxes being released into pens, chased, caught and torn to shreds by frenzied dogs

 Providing live bait for this sport are the trappers, some of whom claim to have been offered $200 for a live coyote while pelts may sell for $12.   The trade in live bait is so lucrative that in 2008, a cooperative seven-state raid of traffickers illegally shipping animals across state lines to penning facilities resulted in 18 arrests,  Animals confiscated in the raid included 25 coyotes, 55 foxes, and 2 bobcats   Also found were 33 cardinals and a moonshine still. This defies trappers’ claims that most animals survive the hunt.

Coyotes, foxes and raccoons are trapped alive; some injured in the process, caged, trucked and sold to penning operators.  Traumatized, they cower in cramped pens until released before a baying mob of hounds.  Comments on trapper websites indicate that the animals are sometimes wounded to ensure capture by the dogs.   Field trials may last two and three days as the victims seek shelter in unfamiliar territory;

 The DNR’s stated concerns about penning include lack of fair chase, and disease transmission between captive and wild animals within enclosures which poses a significant threat to both the wild populations and human beings.  It encourages illegal activities in trafficking from other states.  KY and OH wildlife officials have relayed concerns to Indiana’s DNR about the transportation of wildlife across state lines. Other concerns include privatization and commercialism of wild animals, hunter ethics and public perception and funding for enforcement.  Federal funds from the Pittman-Robertson Act that support DNR activities are ineligible for use in regulating and inspecting services and property of material value to individuals or groups for commercial purposes.  This means that IN taxpayers will be picking up some of the tab for monitoring the running pens.  We will be paying for this small percent of IN Hoosiers who participate in this “blood sport” to kill our wildlife.

At the March NRC meeting, the DNR was against the running pens operating in IN.  Since then, for some reason, they have reversed their thinking. The brutality of penning plus lack of intelligent wildlife practice should ensure that dog-training enclosures are outlawed throughout IN.

 Public comments will be heard at the Nov. 16, 10a.m., NRC meeting to be held at The Garrison at FT Harrison State Park. Although this is a public meeting, the public does not have a right to be heard.  Who may comment is at the discretion of Mr. Poynter, chairman of the Commission.


hendy [Member] said:

Great info, Ruth.

2010-11-06 13:22:45

Ms. Cynical [unverified] said:

I know: let's put politicians in the pen and let them face the dogs....

2010-11-06 15:04:17

Tom Greenacres [unverified] said:

Gonna barf.
The craven DNR did an about face and fell off its high road when it decided to continue allowing penned hunting and tracking. Why would any sane individual want to be associated with something that has not a shred of "sporting" in it?

At least one of the wanker owners of a penned hunting operation pled hardship if his Indiana operation was shut down. Meth cookers can make the same argument.

2010-11-07 07:52:01

Tell The Truth [Member] said:

Tom, that about sums it up. Perfect.

2010-11-07 20:27:16

varangianguard [unverified] said:

"welfare of the (animal)" and a "fair chase"????

Testing the limits of believability here.

2010-11-08 06:11:53

Grant [unverified] said:

The Indiana DNR can rationalize till kingdom come and the result is still the same: WRONG! WRONG!! WRONG!!
This should be outlawed completely. Indiana DNR, stop dancing between the raindrops. Hunters have plenty of leverage without resorting to "penning", and calling it by another name doesn't change a thing. We're not stupid!

2010-11-11 12:22:59

CeAnn [unverified] said:

When the FL Game Commission closed the FL pens. The Chair said "There is no right way to do a wrong thing." And he also said, "no matter at what angle we look at penning, we can not see it as 'fair chase'." FL penning was heavily regulated. That didn't help one bit. The DNR does think Indiana citizens are stupid. Changing the name doesn't fool us one iota. Although Linnea's comments look like there will only be one pen in IN, it is worth noting that the DNR proposal does not reflect that. Please join us for a press conference at 9:30am before the meeting in the lobby of the Garrison.

2010-11-11 16:16:35

Comments are closed.


or Register


Syndicate Blog