Management blinks; Guild wins a round
http://www.ibj.com/html/detail_page.asp?content=170
Advertorial copy, for those mercifully not in the know, is the catch phrase for articles or stories that are built around ads. An advertiser may agree to buy space in a publication, with the understanding that the publication will write a favorable piece about the advertiser's business or products or services involved --- basically promotional material. Typically, magazines and newspapers label that material "advertorial" and mark it as such.
In what many say is an unprecedented move, the Star's bosses -- Star vice president Ali Zoibi and Star managing editor Dennis Ryerson -- had cooked up a scheme in which news staffers -- reporters, copy editors, graphic artists -- would be assigned to write advertorial copy. Normally, such copy is written by writers not in the newsroom but in marketing or promotions departments. They are specifically hired to do that job.
The newspaper Guild strenuously objected to the plan.
Zoibi took his fight to the newsroom (what the Star now calls the information center). After meeting with Guild officers about management's proposal, and hearing their objections, he sent out a memo to the staff. The email was addressed to the Guild and was sharply critical of its position:
"We recently met with you and three other Guild representatives to invite you to join with us, as a cooperative partner, as we work to change our business model. Quite frankly we were expecting a quick and supportive, "yes" given what our future will likely be without these changes.
"Despite repeated requests to join us as we implement changes to benefit all employees, the Guild insists on knowing every detail of a plan that must, by definition, be fluid. We explained to you that we don't have all the answers now but one thing is for certain. We will make these changes with or without your assistance."
As has already been reported here and elsewhere, Zoibi's heavy-handed tactics backfired when the memo ended up on the Poynter Institute's web page.
Several journalism professors are quoted in the IBJ about the wrongness of management's plan:
" 'The proposal that editorial staffers write advertorials is 100-percent wrong," said Ray Begovich, Franklin College journalism professor. "It breaks one of the essential contracts a news-gathering agency has with its audience. The contract is that anything that looks like news or is produced by the news staff should not be paid for."
"Begovich said the practice of having journalists write advertisements is occasionally seen in small markets where the staff is stretched especially thin, but 'there's no excuse for this from a metro daily.'
"That Ryerson might allow this to happen is even more 'stunning,' said IUPUI's (Jim) Brown. (associate dean at the IUPUI School of Journalism).
" 'This goes beyond ethics," Begovich said. "It's good business to keep a firm wall between advertising and editorial. If the public feels the integrity of a newspaper has dropped, that can hurt circulation and that hurts ad sales.
" 'News copy is powerful because it has an unbiased objectivity to it. That's why some advertisers try to make ads that look like news copy.' "
As with any Gannett story, there is a bottom line.
"...management refused to rule out eventually raising the issue again," Schoettle reports.
This won't go away. The Guild is going to have to strap on its leather balls, because these bosses are ruthless.
comments: ruth@ruthholladay.com
Comments
Comments are closed.
Links
- http://harrisontherecord.wordpress.com/
- http://www.sheilakennedy.net/
- http://hadenoughindy.blogspot.com/
- http://www.indyparking.com/
- http://hoosiergardener.com/
- http://gannettblog.blogspot.com/
- http://sharpwordworks.com/blog/
- http://bradburyhouse.blogspot.com/
- http://www.indianabarrister.com/
- http://captaincritic.blogspot.com/
- http://wakeupnaptown.com/
- http://bartonlawllc.com/
- http://indydemocrat.blogspot.com/
- http://www.hoosierpoliticalreport.com/
- http://ipopa.blogspot.com/
- http://www.masson.us/blog/
- http://www.gannettoid.com/
- http://www.howeypolitics.com/
- http://www.indianalawblog.com/
- http://www.poynter.org/
- http://www.editorandpublisher.com/
- http://sadbastards.wordpress.com/
- http://advanceindiana.blogspot.com/
- http://www.munciefreepress.com/
- http://www.bilerico.com/
- http://indytaxdollars.typepad.com/
Archives
- Sep 2016
- May 2016
- Apr 2016
- Aug 2015
- Jul 2015
- May 2015
- Mar 2015
- Oct 2014
- Sep 2014
- Aug 2014
- Jun 2014
- May 2014
- Apr 2014
- Mar 2014
- Feb 2014
- Jan 2014
- Dec 2013
- Nov 2013
- Sep 2013
- Aug 2013
- Jul 2013
- Jun 2013
- May 2013
- Apr 2013
- Mar 2013
- Feb 2013
- Jan 2013
- Dec 2012
- Nov 2012
- Oct 2012
- Sep 2012
- Aug 2012
- Jul 2012
- Jun 2012
- May 2012
- Apr 2012
- Mar 2012
- Feb 2012
- Jan 2012
- Dec 2011
- Nov 2011
- Oct 2011
- Sep 2011
- Aug 2011
- Jul 2011
- Jun 2011
- May 2011
- Apr 2011
- Mar 2011
- Feb 2011
- Jan 2011
- Dec 2010
- Nov 2010
- Oct 2010
- Sep 2010
- Aug 2010
- Jul 2010
- Jun 2010
- May 2010
- Apr 2010
- Mar 2010
- Feb 2010
- Jan 2010
- Dec 2009
- Nov 2009
- Oct 2009
- Sep 2009
- Aug 2009
- Jul 2009
- Jun 2009
- May 2009
- Apr 2009
- Mar 2009
- Feb 2009
- Jan 2009
- Dec 2008
- Nov 2008
- Oct 2008
- Sep 2008
- Aug 2008
- Jul 2008
- Jun 2008
- May 2008
- Apr 2008
- Mar 2008
- Feb 2008
- Jan 2008
- Dec 2007
- Nov 2007
- Oct 2007
- Sep 2007
- Aug 2007
- Jul 2007
- Jun 2007
- May 2007
- Apr 2007
- Mar 2007
- Feb 2007
- Jan 2007
- Dec 2006
- Nov 2006
- Oct 2006
- Sep 2006
- Aug 2006
- Jul 2006